The Left Berlin News & Comment

This is the archive template

“Germany, you’re not getting rid of us until you stop supporting genocide”

Interview with Jara Nassar from the Occupy against Occupation Camp opposite the Bundestag


17/06/2025

So here we are again. Could you just remind people who you are?

Hi, I’m Jara. I’m one of the press speakers and organizers of Besetzung gegen Besatzung (Occupy against Occupation), which is a Palestine Solidarity camp in front of the German parliament, the Bundestag. Two days ago, on Friday the 13th, we set up for a third time to protest Germany’s weapons exports to Israel and the ongoing genocide,

Could you also remind us what happened to the first two camps?

Gladly. The first time we set up was last year, April 8th, 2024. We set up our tents out of a random push for wanting to do something different, because the genocide in Gaza had been going on for six months. We had a wonderful 19 days of workshops and panels and protests and all sorts of people coming and having community space up until the 26th of April, where we got brutally evicted by the Berlin police .

The police gave us about an hour’s notice. They showed up on Friday morning with riot gear, locked down almost all of the streets coming to the camp, and proceeded to evict us very brutally, smash our stuff, and injure and arrest a lot of people. 

Then we had a second camp in November and December of 2024 that lasted for six weeks. We packed that one up just before Christmas. And now we’re back. 

Why now? 

The right time to protest for Palestine is always — but specifically now we’re standing in solidarity with the Sumud convoys, the march to Gaza, and the Freedom Flotilla, which are all projects that are trying to break the 18 year long siege and and naval blockade of Gaza. 

Gaza has been under a complete siege for more than 90 days now, which means that barely any aid, food, medical supplies, fuel have been let in, all things that are extremely necessary to the survival of the people there. Israel has been blocking all of it, and people are trying to break that siege.

How do you think that the camp is contributing towards breaking the siege?

Germany is the second largest weapons exporter to Israel, which means that our domestic protest here is incredibly important as part of a global solidarity movement to stop Israeli war crimes and crimes against humanity, and the ongoing occupation of Palestine. If we can stop the weapons getting delivered from Germany, that would be a massive blow to the Israeli war machine. 

Some people in Germany like to think that they can’t really do anything, but Germany is one of the staunchest supporters of Israel. This is very much a protest in the belly of the beast.,

The camp is directly opposite the Bundestag. If people visit, when should they come and what can they expect?

Come anytime. We’re here 24/7. During the daytime, you can expect Community Care workshops, readings, and interesting conversations with people from all walks of life. In the afternoon, you can expect workshops, rallies, drumming, and then in the evenings we usually have a film screening. 

Because it’s June, and it gets dark so late, the films start at 9.30. Tomorrow, (Monday 16th), we’re screening No Other Land and then having a discussion about it. 

Where could people find a program of what’s happening when?

They can find that on our Instagram, our Telegram, or our Website. They all have the name besetzunggegenbesatzung.

How long do you expect to be there? You said you were brutally forced out the first time round, and last time you packed up for Christmas. Is there a plan for this time?

We have now registered for 10 days until 23rd June, and then we will see whether we continue or consider this a success, pack up and continue pressuring the German government in other forms. Even when the camp gets packed up, that doesn’t mean we stop.

What exactly are you protesting? You said you’re in solidarity with the Convoy and the Madleen, but as you were setting up, Israel attacked Iran. Is that part of your protest?

Our protest is against Israel’s ongoing settler colonial regime that has expansive ambitions all over the region. Not only is Israel attacking Iran, but it is also still bombing and killing people in Lebanon and Syria.

Our protest is against the entire Israeli war machine and the German complicity in it, because all of this would not be possible without German weapons, bombs, diplomacy, and finance.

Do you get a sense that things are changing in Germany? Now even Friedrich Merz and Annalena Baerbock are saying that Israel is going too far. Is anything practically changing in German politics, or are these just words?

So far, these are just words of a regime that wants to establish itself as the dominant military power in Europe. Germany strategically sees that more and more of the world’s tide is turning against Israel. It would be naive to believe that the German government has actually come to a moral awakening. As long as Germany benefits from this war machine, with all of its weapons production, this will continue.

But there is a narrative shift, and we do hope that more and more of the German people wake up to what’s happening and start protesting. It’s not enough to sit at home and quietly disapprove, which seems to be the case for most people in Germany. Now is really the time to get up and start doing something.

A friend of mine was at Camp yesterday, and she said there were more Germans there than she was expecting. Are you witnessing this too?

There were definitely more Germans than expected yesterday, because there was a protest around the corner that was co-organized by ver.di. I would say that proportionally there were definitely more old white Germans than at any of the Palestinian or diaspora organized protests that I’ve seen so far. 

We do welcome and encourage that shift, but we don’t have people coming up to us and saying: “Oh, I’m so sorry. I should have been here a year and three months ago when you first set up”. If you want accountability, that means that people need to reckon with their own role. If they only wake up late, that’s cool. Good that you woke up. Now make up for it.

At least it’s good that some people are changing.

Some people, yes, but without a fundamental shift, that’s just window dressing.

Today there’s also a protest for Veteranentag against German militarization. Are you finding ways of linking up with this? Is this an opportunity to address young Germans who are worried about conscription, but are not yet necessarily thinking about Palestine?

There’s obviously a big connection between Germany gearing up for war, changing its economy to produce more weapons, and now edging closer to reintroducing enforced conscription. We are linked up with the organizers of the Veteranentag protests. We absolutely support them. We mobilize people to go there and then afterwards come to the camp. 

We do hope that this is something that we can address within the camp for young Germans, or older Germans who are worried that their kids are going to go to war. All of these things are connected.

Back to the camp. You say you’re organising workshops. Who is running these workshops? Can someone just turn up and offer their own workshop?

Absolutely. Anyone who is in solidarity with Palestine and wants to offer a workshop, a panel, anything, they are very welcome to come. This is not organized by a closed group. It’s very DIY organizing. Yesterday, we had someone do a yoga workshop that was relatively spontaneous. 

If people want to get involved, there’s a daily plenum at 12 noon. But also join the Telegram, chat, text us and just come by. We’re here 24/7.

Last time you had some bigger events with people like Michael Barenboim speaking. Is there anything on that level planned this time round?

We’re working on it. We do hope that we will get that. Stay tuned.

Do you think there’s a chance of getting people from the Freedom Flotilla along?

Two members of the flotilla were just deported back to Berlin after they were illegally abducted to Israel. We do hope that we will get them here to the camp, but obviously being abducted by Israel and then deported is a little bit of stress. We admire and honour their commitment. They may first need a couple of days to rest.

[Editor’s Note: Yasemin Acar, who was on the Flotilla, will now be speaking at the camp at 6pm on Wednesday, 18th June]

People can camp as well. Do you have spare tents? Or should people bring their own? 

We do have some spare tents, but we also have a great amount of campers right now. So we encourage everyone to come and camp with us, and bring your tents and sleeping bags. If you don’t have any, we do have stuff here. 

And if you’re in Berlin and you have camping gear, but you can’t camp, drop it off. We do our best to give this stuff back, unless the police destroy it again.

What about people not in Berlin? People in Berlin should come to the camp and get involved. Is there any way people outside Berlin can support you? 

People outside of Berlin can share the message. We have some events that we’re going to be live streaming. They can also reach out. We’re happy to do a Skillshare for how to organize your own protest camp. 

You are more than welcome to come here on 21st June, when the United for Gaza march is mobilizing people to come to Berlin. We very cordially invite anyone and everyone who is traveling to Berlin for that march to bring your tents. Come camp with us.

You talked about being attacked by the police. We are currently sitting in the camp and can see a number of police looking at us. What’s the likelihood that the police will try and break you up again?

I think for now, it’s rather low, because after the first brutal eviction, they did get a lot of bad press, and we are now very linked with international organizations that have an eye on us. If something happens, we can scandalize it. 

But of course we do see the absurd administrative obstruction of the police. Yesterday, they put up these metal barricades which mean that the entire front side of the camp is now locked off. They told us that they would just be there for a march which was passing by. We said: this amazing march was pro-Palestine. You don’t need to protect us against it.

We asked the police if they’d take them down. And they said, no, these will now stay. This is what we see from the German police and the Berlin police especially. As soon as the repressive measure is in place, it will stay. It’s completely absurd. 

It’s obviously intended to make us harder to reach, to make us appear like criminals, to make us feel caged in, fenced in from 2 sides. We hope that we can get the police to take it down, seeing as this is completely absurd and unnecessary. But we’re also not going to be intimidated. 

I know some people with precarious residency status who say that they’re not sure whether they’ll come here, because if they’re arrested the repercussions are much more. What would you say to them?

Unfortunately, that is always a risk. At the moment, we have had three arrests. But there are very low risk ways to get engaged. There was never a situation where the whole camp got kettled and everyone was arrested, or we couldn’t get out anymore. 

We do have people here with precarious residency status, and the people with the European and German passports are aware of that and have the solidarity to then put themselves on the line a bit more.

Is there anything we haven’t talked about that you’d like to say?

On June 21st there’s also an open house at the Rotes Rathaus, close to Alexanderplatz. We all know that our mayor, Kai Wegner, is very complicit in the genocide in Gaza. He has said that there is no genocide in Gaza full stop. So this is a good opportunity to go and confront him.

Apart from that, the Camp is just a really nice place to come and meet people and talk strategy. We have to reaffirm that, even with everything going on, the focus is always Gaza. The last internet cable in Gaza has just been bombed by Israel. They have a complete communication blackout. And that is the people we are fighting for, because those are the ones who are in most danger. 

If you do close down the camp, what happens then?

Then we move on to other forms, and we might be back. We always have our tents in the back of our minds. Many of us who are at the first and second camps are really happy to be back here. Germany, you’re not getting rid of us until you stop supporting genocide.

Red Flag: Seven years in prison for a tweet in support of Palestine?

In his weekly column, Nathaniel Flakin calls for solidarity with the railway worker Anasse Kazib from Paris

When the German government insists on ramping up military spending to the tune of half a trillion euros, European leaders assure us this isn’t about shoring up billionaires’ profits. No, they say, militarism is necessary to defend our freedom, democracy, and basic rights.

But rearmament isn’t very popular. Germany’s unflinching support for the genocide in Gaza is opposed by up to 80 percent of people. So in their struggle to defend their “democracy,” imperialist politicians have been attacking our democratic rights. 

In Berlin, police repression has become completely unhinged. The US government has carried out unprecedented attacks on freedom of speech, such as the attempted deportation of Mahmoud Khalil. Even in France, where the authoritarian-centrist president Emmanuel Macron recently began criticizing Israel and announced plans to recognize a Palestinian state, the judicial apparatus is taking aim at pro-Palestinian voices.

On Wednesday, the rail worker and union activist Anasse Kazib will appear in a Parisian court on charges of “apology for terrorism.” If convicted, he faces up to seven years in prison or a fine of €100,000. His “crime” consists of a few tweets criticizing EU and French leaders for their support for mass murder. 

The son of Moroccan immigrants to France, Kazib has been fighting for the rights of fellow rail workers for over a decade, organizing protests and strikes against privatization plans and pension reforms. He has run as a candidate for the Trotskyist organization Révolution Permanente.

The French state has investigated different left-wing politicians, including Rima Hassan from the European parliament (and more recently the Gaza Freedom Flotilla), for tweets about Gaza. The persecution of Kazib is a test to see how far they can go in criminalizing opposition. If he is convicted, it will make it harder for anyone to speak up against the genocide — and if he is victorious, then it will throw sand in the gears of repression.

This is why over 1,000 public figures declared their solidarity for Kazib, including the Nobel Prize winners Adolfo Pérez Esquivel and Annie Ernaux. Well-known activists and and artists like Angela Davis, Tariq Ali, Pablo Iglesias, Adèle Haenel, Yanis Varoufakis, Nancy Fraser, Brian Eno, and Ken Loach signed the petition, as did leaders of the Palestine solidarity movement like Mohammed el-Kurd, Rashid Khalidi, Noura Erakat, Ilan Pappé, Chris Hedges, Abby Martin, and Norman Finkelstein.

There will be rallies in defense of Kazib on Tuesday, the day before the trial begins, in over a dozen cities worldwide. Activists in Berlin will gather at the French embassy at the Brandenburg Gate, on June 17 at 17:00.

At a rally in Paris last month, Kazib spoke to 2,000 people about the need for internationalism. “If we are not profoundly internationalist today,” he said, “we will be nationalist tomorrow”. As the big capitalist powers lurch toward ever greater conflagrations, they will try to whip us into a national frenzy. But the main enemy is at home. We need to stand with revolutionary worker-politicians like Kazib, and with everyone who is being targeted for solidarity.

Red Flag is a weekly column on Berlin politics that Nathaniel Flakin has been writing since 2020. After moving through different homes, it now appears at The Left Berlin.

20 June 1967: Muhammad Ali arrested for “draft dodging”

This week in working class history

On June 20th, Black boxer Mohammed Ali was convicted of draft dodging. The all-white jury made its decision in 21 minutes. Ali was fined $10,000, was sentenced to 5 years in jail, and was forced to surrender his passport. He had already been stripped of his world heavyweight boxing title. On the same day, the US Congress voted 337-29 to extend the draft for four more years and 385-19 to make desecrating the flag a federal crime.

The background was the escalation of the war in Vietnam, which still had the support of over half the US population. Ali defied this trend. When he was called up, he said: “Why should they ask me to put on a uniform and go ten thousand miles from home and drop bombs and bullets on brown people in Vietnam while so-called Negro people in Louisville are treated like dogs and denied simple human rights?” Later, he said: “Man, I ain’t got no quarrel with them Viet Cong. No Viet Cong ever called me nigger.”

This was not Ali’s first political act. Frustrated with the timidity of the Civil Rights movement, he joined the Nation of Islam and befriended Malcolm X. Ali’s opposition to war and racism was accompanied by a class consciousness. Years later, he said: “It wasn’t just Black people being drafted. The government had a system where the rich man’s son went to college, and the poor man’s son went to war.”

Ali avoided jail, but for 3½ years in his mid-20s, the peak of his physical condition, he was banned from boxing. He spent this time speaking out against war and racism. In 1968, his speech “Black is Best” attracted 4,000 students and staff at Howard University. He made many similar speeches to large audiences, which helped build the growing movement against war. By August 1968, support for the war had sunk to 27%.

While the public celebrates his athletic prowess, Ali’s politics are often ignored. However, in the 1960s and 1970s, both Democrat and Republican administrations considered him a national threat and bugged his phone. When John Carlos and Tommie Smith made the Black Power salute at the 1968 Olympics, one of their demands was: “Restore Muhammad Ali’s title.” Ali was unrepentant. Speaking out against his sentence, Ali said: “I have nothing to lose by standing up for my beliefs. So I’ll go to jail. We’ve been in jail for four hundred years.”

Gary Lineker and Labour

Lineker should be a natural Starmerite. So why is he causing the Labour leader so many problems?


16/06/2025

A long time ago—it must have been the mid to late 1980s—leading English footballer Gary Lineker appeared on Desert Island Discs. For those of you unfamiliar with old British radio shows, in Desert Island Discs, a personality is asked to name the eight records they would take with them on a desert island. To be honest, this is just a conceit for a programme that is essentially a celebrity interview.

At the time, Lineker was playing in Barcelona in one of the first significant waves of British footballers playing abroad. Not all of them adapted to the new conditions equally. Ian Rush famously was reported as saying that being in Italy was like “living in a foreign country”. It is still unclear whether this was meant as a joke, but the quote embodied an attitude of Brits refusing to integrate.

Lineker was different. On the radio programme, he explained how he and his family were not just learning Spanish—they were also learning Catalan. This sounded like more than the words of someone who was looking after his PR. Lineker seemed genuinely interested in other countries.

Lineker was not a rebel. He knew his place and stayed in line. First as a highly successful footballer, then as a pundit. But he was well loved as a good bloke, someone who enjoyed watching and talking about football. If he was known for anything outside the sport, it was for advertising Walkers crisps, which were produced in his hometown of Leicester.

Lineker and Brexit

Fast forward over 30 years. In 2018, Lineker backed the campaign for a second Brexit referendum. The so-called “liberal intelligentsia”, which includes the people currently running the Labour Party, welcomed his intervention, not least because he was largely speaking their language. To understand this, we need to dispel some myths about Brexit.

It is now widely assumed that the Brexit debate was between racists who wanted to prevent migrants entering Britain and anti-racists who supported freedom of movement. This was not the case, especially if you looked at the leaders of the campaigns.

The figurehead of the pro-Brexit campaign was Nigel Farage, a racist former supporter of the National Front. But the other side was not led by socialists, or even liberals, but by austerity prime minister David Cameron. The argument was not about whether we needed borders to limit migration into Britain, but whether those borders should be in the English Channel or the Mediterranean.

Of course, many anti-racists campaigned against Brexit, but the EU project was always closely tied with Fortress Europe and the idea that “our” values, that is the values of white Europeans, are more important than those of dark-skinned Muslims from the Global South.

Lineker as anti-Corbyn?

There was another aspect of the Brexit discussion which profited Labour’s right wing. The Brexit vote was in 2016. This meant that the election campaigns of both 2017 and 2019 were dominated not by Jeremy Corbyn’s slightly radical manifesto, but by Brexit.

Lineker’s statement was welcomed by the Labour Right, not just because it fitted their narrative, but also because it provided another distraction away from Corbyn’s reforming agenda. Indeed, Lineker’s Brexit Twitter campaign was preceded one year earlier by another tweet: “Bin Corbyn”.

In 2017, former editor of Q magazine Danny Kelly wrote an article for Esquire entitled: “How Gary Lineker Became the Voice of Liberal Britain”. In the article, Kelly argued that “smart people have been moved to declare him the Unofficial Leader of the Opposition”.

In the article, Kelly refers to few political statements by Lineker outside vague mentions of Brexit, refugees and Donald Trump. More emphasis is played on Lineker’s cosmopolitan attitude, media presence and ease in front of a camera.

The timing of Kelly’s article was not accidental. It was in the middle of Corbyn’s election campaigns, which were sabotaged by leading party members. It appears to be part of the trend by the Labour right at the time to promote someone—anyone—as an alternative to Corbyn.

This shows the Lineker of the late 2010s to be ideologically aligned to Keir Starmer. In April 2020, when Starmer replaced Corbyn as Labour leader, Lineker retweeted Starmer’s acceptance speech with the comment: “Well-chosen words”.

Ukraine invasion

Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Lineker asked foreign secretary Liz Truss if the Conservative Party would “hand back their donations from Russian donors”. One week after the invasion, he interviewed Ukraine and Manchester City midfielder Oleksandr Zinchenko on the BBC.

During the interview, Zinchenko said: “The people are starving there. The people are sleeping underground, in bunkers, whatever. They cannot live a proper life.” Lineker’s follow-up question was to ask Zinchenko if he was proud to be a Ukrainian. Later, both men described the importance of people flying Ukrainian flags at football matches.

Let us be clear. One week into an illegal invasion, the words of both Lineker and Zinchenko are perfectly reasonable. Indeed, they are largely consistent with Lineker’s later comments on Gaza. But, knowing what we do now, we see huge double standards in the media reaction.

Imagine the outcry if Lineker had asked a footballer from Gaza about Israel’s murderous assault on their country, and whether this made them feel a proud Palestinian. Imagine if he’d have called for more Palestinian flags at games. Imagine if this interview had been carried out with a huge Palestinian flag in the background.

Attack on Suella Braverman

Lineker had often been vocal on the subject of refugees. In 2020, following a suggestion by Boris Johnson to make deportation easier, he tweeted: “Can we make it clear that not everyone in this country is heartless and completely without empathy. These poor people deserve the help of their fellow human beings.”

After some criticised him for hypocrisy, Lineker put up two refugees while they were looking for permanent accommodation. He later said: “to listen to their experiences, have dinner with them, and become friends with them was really something very, very special, and I think it’s been a really good experience, particularly for my boys to help them understand how lucky they are.”

In 2023, he upped the ante. Responding to a call by Tory Home Secretary Suella Braverman to “stop the boats”, he tweeted: “Good heavens, this is beyond awful.” When some of his followers complained, he replied: “We take far fewer refugees than other major European countries. This is just an immeasurably cruel policy directed at the most vulnerable people in language that is not dissimilar to that used by Germany in the 30s, and I’m out of order?”

Lineker was temporarily sacked by the BBC for these tweets. One of his defenders was Leader of the Opposition Keir Starmer, who said: “The BBC is not acting impartially by caving in to Tory MPs who are complaining about Gary Lineker. They’ve got this one badly wrong and now they’re very, very exposed, as is the government.”

You wonder whether Starmer would support Lineker today. The official Labour Party Facebook page has recently been running a series of posts attacking the Tories for not deporting enough people. A typical post (from 2nd June) reads: “The Tories ran an open borders experiment. This ends now. Labour is taking back control, smashing the criminal smuggling gangs and securing our borders, for good.”

In May 2025, Starmer echoed Tory bigot Enoch Powell by saying that without strict immigration controls “we risk becoming an island of strangers”. Surely Lineker felt ill at ease that the British prime minister was now attacking Tories like Braverman for being too soft.

Gaza

Lineker’s decisive break with the Starmer project undoubtedly came over Gaza. Most of us are aware of what happened, but let me briefly summarize. In November 2023, Lineker tweeted an interview between Owen Jones and Israeli professor Raz Segal accusing Israel of genocide. Then, 16 months later, he was one of 500 media personalities who condemned the BBC for pulling the documentary Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone.

Recently, Lineker was sacked again for sharing an Instagram post from Palestine Lobby that included an image of a rat. Accompanying the post, Lineker made the following comment: “It’s beyond depraved, what they’re going through, unimaginable. Every day people are losing their children, their brothers and sisters. I don’t know how the world thinks this is OK.” 

After an outcry, he soon deleted both the clip and the comment. When challenged on his views, Lineker said: “I know where I stand on this … the mass murder of thousands of children is probably something we should have a little opinion on.” Surely this matters more than any manufactured allegations of antisemitism.

Lineker was quite clear about who he held responsible: “We still seem to be on the side of the people who are doing this. We’re still supplying arms. And you think, ‘Wow, how?’ The vast majority of people see it for what it is now. Unfortunately, the Government’s not doing much about it. It comes down to power and money.” At the end of May, Lineker joined 300 actors, singers and activists calling on Starmer’s government to end all arms sales to Israel.

This is no sudden conversion. One year ago, Lineker told Mehdi Hasan: “There’s a lot of heavy lobbying on people to be quiet, so I understand why most people refrain, but I’m getting on a bit now. I’m fairly secure, and I can’t be silent about what’s happening there. It’s so utterly awful.”

Conclusion

Gary Lineker is not a revolutionary socialist. Owen Jones called him a “classic liberal”. He has called himself “quintessentially a floating voter”. On Gaza, he has tweeted: “Israelis have a right to defend themselves.” As recently as 23rd April this year, he appeared alongside Starmer at an event to “fight for our flag and what it represents”.

The martyrdom of St. Gary has little to do with the radicalism of anything that Lineker has said. It is more a sign of how far to the right the discussion on Palestine has shifted in the British media and politics. Lineker may be an instinctive Starmerite, but the British government’s failure on Gaza, and on politics in general, has led him to clash with Starmer—a man who loves football so much that he takes free tickets to watch Arsenal from an Executive box at the Emirates stadium.

For a while, Lineker was the liberal’s liberal—someone who speaks truth to power, albeit politely, while always avoiding the tricky subjects. He outraged right-wing bloggers, but didn’t say anything to annoy the people who had taken over the Labour Party. But speaking out, first on refugee rights, and now on Gaza, he has come into conflict with Starmer’s government.

Since he became Labour leader, Keir Starmer has defined himself by what he is not. First he was not-Corbyn, then not-the Tories, and now he is not-Nigel Farage. Such a strategy might bring short-term gains, but it is an insult to an electorate that is looking for something to believe in. It is little surprise that less than 1 year after Labour’s landslide election victory, they are now polling 23%—6% behind Farage’s Reform UK.

Simply by having an opinion and speaking up, Lineker has offered a pole of attraction to Starmer’s Labour. Of course, a few liberal words by a now former football pundit is not the same as the fighting mass organisation that we need to build a different society. But in a time of genocide and of a political landscape which is dominated by neoliberal parties like Labour, the Tories, and Reform UK, Lineker is addressing our audience. This is something the Left must build on.

France: Palestine movement moves up a gear

Rima Hassan MEP returns from imprisonment in Israel

On Saturday 14th June mass demonstrations were called in Paris and around the country by all five major national union confederations, from the radical Solidaires to the far less combative CFDT. This follows a week of impressive solidarity action.

The Freedom Flotilla Twelve include MEP Rima Hassan, of the left-wing party La France Insoumise (LFI). Illegally kidnapped by Israeli soldiers in the middle of the night, in international waters, along with the other eleven, she was imprisoned in Israel last Monday. 

Fifteen years ago when another solidarity boat was attacked by Israel, the Zionist state preferred to execute in cold blood several of the unarmed activists. This time, they found themselves in a prison cell. Rima’s captors tried to pressurize her to sign a document recognizing that she had entered Israel illegally. “I’ll smash your head against the wall if you don’t sign this. We’ll deal with this in our way” she was told. She refused, along with most of her comrades. When she wrote “Free Palestine” on her cell wall, she was shackled hand and foot and put in solitary confinement, where she began a hunger strike. Israeli authorities abandoned the idea of putting her in front of an Israeli court, and placed her on a flight home, during which far-right Israeli passengers threatened her.

On Monday 9th of June, while the safety of the kidnapped activists was still unknown, large demos were held across the country, some of the biggest demonstrations called on the same day for several decades. Every evening since, thousands have gathered to protest in Paris and in other towns, including protest camps in central Paris lasting several days. On Friday the rally in Paris welcomed Rima Hassan home. In her speech she insisted that “the next boat is ready to sail”. Jean-Luc Mélenchon,  leader of the France Insoumise declared that the flotilla was “A success which did more in a few days than the governments of the world have done” for Gaza. The same week dockers in Marseille had refused to handle spare parts for the Israeli massacre machine.

Macron and his Prime Minister Bayrou showed no objection to the elected French representative, Rima Hassan, being snatched in international waters. Macron pleaded that the Freedom Flotilla crew be allowed to return home, without a word of protest against the Israeli actions. Bayrou claimed that Rima and the others were just involved in a “publicity stunt”. At the time of writing, three of the kidnapped crew, including Yanis Mhamdi, a French journalist at the online publication Blast, have not yet been freed. The French government is unconcerned, too busy applauding Israel’s bombing of Iran.

Faced with mass public support for Palestine, Macron has once again denounced the famine imposed on Gaza and declared France’s ‘determination’ to recognize a Palestinian state, but not yet and not without conditions! What he wants is a Palestinian ‘Bantustan’ with a flag, but no army, and a government chosen by Western imperialism in consultation with the genocide team in Tel Aviv.

Macron’s support for the genocide continues even as he denounces it. His government has just approved the presence of Israel at a major arms fair held outside Paris next week. Nine Israeli companies will sell their arms ‘tested in combat’ on the people of Gaza.

Mainstream media has tried to downplay the freedom flotilla story, as well as telling lies about it. The release of the French MEP, Rima Hassan,  from illegal detention by a French ally did not make the main national evening news and the 24-hour news channels had the Israeli ambassador, the Israeli army spokesman and their buddies chatting about the Freedom Flotilla calling it a ‘pleasure cruise’. They haven’t invited MEP Rima Hassan on their shows.

Despite the stronger tradition of mass protest in France than in the UK, in France the Palestine rallies have been smaller this past year than across the Channel, so this week’s mobilization has been a much needed boost. Having a largeish political formation (LFI have 71 MPs and 9 MEPs) 100% committed to stopping the genocide is tremendously useful.

This movement around the Freedom Flotilla has reinforced the position of the France Insoumise as the centre of gravity of radical politics in France. Other forces within the fragile electoral alliance which allowed the Left to have the largest group in parliament after last year’s elections, have reacted diversely. Olivier Faure of the Socialist Party denounced the illegal boarding of the Freedom Flotilla ship, the Madleen. Leaders of the Communist Party and the Greens made similar declarations.

But much of the Left, along with Macron, has been more interested in attacking the France Insoumise. Rima Hassan declared that Palestinian resistance was legitimate, and as a result two ministers asked if her French nationality could be withdrawn. Furthermore, this week, at the Socialist Party’s biennial conference, one MP, Jérôme Guedj, was applauded for calling Jean-Luc Mélenchon an ‘antisemitic bastard’. The Socialist Party leadership has so far refused to dissociate themselves from these insults.

Widespread sectarianism has stopped most of the radical and revolutionary left from defending the France Insoumise from the huge smear campaign rolled out in recent months, identical to the one against Jeremy Corbyn a few years back. Every left-wing activist should oppose it.

Rallies are planned next week against the arms fair in Le Bourget where Israel will be an honoured guest. This needs to be the beginning of a deepening of the movement. Israel must fall.